The Best Superhero Movies By Genre

Today marks the 20th anniversary of the release of the original Blade on August 21, 1998. The film kicked off the modern era of superhero films (or at least Marvel films), and also deftly combined comic book stylings with horror. Hence, ComingSoon.net is finding the Best Superhero Movies By Genre, and you can check out our list in the gallery below!

A lot of audiences don’t realize this, but “superhero” is not a genre, it’s just a character type. “Comic Book” isn’t a genre either, it’s just a medium, hence why you don’t hear comic book movies like Ghost World discussed too often in relation to Thor: The Dark World. Despite not being based on comics, movies like RoboCop and Darkman are superhero movies, but their genre is sci-fi action or horror film. A superhero movie can literally be any genre, which is something we try to explore in this list.

Even within the Blade trilogy you see a genre shift in each one, with the horror being dominant in the first, and slowly shifting towards action in the second and third films. Each film in Marvel’s Captain America trilogy explored a different genre, with the first being primarily a war movie, the second a paranoid thriller and the third being more a globetrotting action adventure.

What genres have the worlds of superheroes overlooked? What is your favorite genre to see superheroes in? Let us know in the comments below!

The Best Superhero Movies By Genre

Best Horror Superhero Movie: Blade

The first Blade movie deftly combined martial arts, action and vampiric horror for a potent bloody cocktail. Wesley Snipes proves an appropriately low-key vampire hunter for the genre, allowing the world around him to be that much more crazy.
Best Comedic Superhero Movie: Deadpool

Ryan Reynolds took a page from the Ferris Bueller playbook and brought a fourth-wall breaking irreverence to superheroics that hadn't really been seen before, especially with an R-rating.
Best Sci-Fi Superhero Movie: Superman

People tend to forget that the movie that kicked off the modern-day superhero movie as we know it was very much a sci-fi movie. The opening with Marlon Brando as Jor-El on the planet Krypton helped set the stage for Kal-El's abilities, and framed it as a literal alien immigrant story.
Best Western Superhero Movie: The Mask of Zorro

The character of Zorro had existed for decades on both the big and small screen, but it was the 1997 Antonio Banderas iteration that finally gave the swashbuckling character the big budget western he deserved.
Best War Superhero Movie: Wonder Woman

Director Patty Jenkins may have cut Wonder Woman from the same cloth as Captain America: The First Avenger, but unlike that Marvel World War II film chose not to go the ra ra patriotic route. Instead she portrayed the battlefields of World War I as grim places of desolation and death, with Diana struggling with the literal God of War to end the conflict.
Best Fantasy Superhero Movie: Thor

Fantasy is tricky: Go too far in one direction and you having the cartoonish camp of Masters of the Universe, and too far in the other direction you have a grimdark heavy metal album cover. Marvel struck just the right fantasy tone with the first Thor movie, with the second being a little too generic and the third more in the sci-fi comedy vein.
Best Romance Superhero Movie: The Wolverine

It's surprising how little romance there is in superhero films, with a love story typically relegated to a B-plot. Like the Frank Miller limited series the film took its inspiration from, the love story between Logan (Hugh Jackman) and Mariko (Tao Okamoto) is a driving force in The Wolverine. With as much action as it has it's hard to characterize it as a pure romance movie, but it's the closest major film to the romance genre.
Best Family Superhero Movie: The Incredibles

Director Brad Bird understands that family films don't have to mean kiddie films, hence why The Incredibles is perhaps the most intense film Pixar has ever made. It also literally has the idea of family at its core, specifically a family of superheroes learning to embrace their powers.
Best Thriller Superhero Movie: Unbreakable

M. Night Shyamalan's Unbreakable was such a low-key superhero movie that it was marketed as a supernatural thriller, kind of like its successor Split. Its a great example of what you can do when you ignore genre conventions.
Best Crime Superhero Movie: The Dark Knight

Christopher Nolan looked to Michael Mann's Heat as inspiration for the kind of movie he wanted to make to followup 2005's Batman Begins. What followed was a brilliant crime film about cops (and the Caped Crusader) vs mob enforcers and a wild card terrorist in Heath Ledger's Joker.
Best Teen Superhero Movie: Chronicle

Director Josh Trank and screenwriter Max Landis redefined both the superhero and found footage concepts with this movie about three teens who unwittingly gain superpowers and what they would then do with them.
Best Heist Superhero Movie: Ant-Man

Marvel understands better than any studio that their movies can explore varied genres, and Ant-Man took the heist film to new heights (small heights to be exact). There are three major heist sequences in the film, all staged with breakneck pace and wit.