Filmmaker Sanjay Leela Bhansali, known for his meticulous direction and ability to draw stellar performances from his actors, recently addressed the reception of his latest project, Heeramandi: The Diamond Bazaar. The period drama, which features a star-studded cast including his niece Sharmin Segal, has been the subject of both praise and critique, particularly regarding Sharmin’s performance as Alamzeb.
Sharmin, who made her acting debut with Bhansali’s 2019 production Malaal, plays the daughter of Heeramandi brothel madam Mallikajaan, portrayed by Manisha Koirala. Her character dreams of escaping the courtesan’s fate, a role that has proven to be challenging. Despite her efforts, Sharmin’s portrayal has faced criticism from audiences who felt her performance was lackluster compared to her more experienced co-stars.
“She kept saying, ‘Mama, I’ll underplay'” : Sanjay Leela Bhansali on Heeramandi’s Alamzeb
In an exclusive discussion, Bhansali shared insights into his niece’s approach and his perspective on her performance. “She kept saying, ‘Mama, I’ll underplay.’ I said, ‘Underplay? Are you thinking I’m going to ask you to overplay?’” Bhansali revealed, underscoring the balance he sought in her acting.
Bhansali acknowledged the criticism but expressed admiration for Sharmin’s “new energy.” He noted, “I know that they (the new generation of actors) love me as much. I can see it in the way they ask me, ‘Are you happy? Should we do one more take? Can we do it one more time? Are you okay?’ I can see that love in their eyes. Now that’s very rare.”
Sharmin’s portrayal of Alamzeb has indeed sparked debate, but Bhansali’s confidence in her potential remains unshaken. “Each actor brings something unique to the table, and with Sharmin, it’s her fresh perspective and enthusiasm,” he added.
The director also shared his experience working with his first leading lady, Manisha Koirala, who returned to collaborate with him after 15 years. Koirala’s dedication to the role of Mallikajaan was evident, as Bhansali recounted her commitment to spending hours applying mehendi to perfect her character’s look. “She sat on the set every time for 7 hours, putting mehendi and then giving two shots. It’s unbearable. And yet she gave me the best takes in those two shots. The scene in which she says, ‘Chaand baramde mein utarta nahi.’ I knew she got her sur there itself. She looked just splendid.”
Despite the mixed reviews for Sharmin, Bhansali remains optimistic about her future in the industry. “So each one is giving me something to take home,” he concluded, indicating his belief in the growth and evolution of his actors.
